This page contains the full record of a successful legal challenge brought against the New York City Parking Violations Bureau after a parking ticket was issued alleging that the vehicle was parked in a “No Parking” zone at 6:59 PM — just one minute before the restriction ended at 7:00 PM. The case ultimately reached the New York Supreme Court, where the court ruled that the City failed to meet its burden of proof and dismissed the summons.
The documents below walk through the entire process from start to finish, including the original summons, the online hearing request, the administrative hearing decision, the appeal filings, the City’s opposition papers, our reply memorandum, and the final Supreme Court decision. The central issue in the case was whether the City could establish a violation based solely on a ticket alleging a violation that may have occurred within seconds of the lawful parking time, despite a detailed denial and without presenting any additional evidence regarding the exact timing or accuracy of the officer’s timekeeping methods.
In dismissing the summons, the court held that once credible evidence was presented disputing the alleged violation, the burden shifted back to the City to prove its case with substantial evidence — something it failed to do. The decision serves as an example of how even relatively minor cases can raise important issues involving fairness, evidence, administrative procedure, and the limits of governmental authority.
Our Recent Win Against The New York City Parking Violations Bureau
PRIOR RESULTS DO NOT GUARANTEE A SIMILAR OUTCOME.